Editorial Review Submission Reviewer InformationReviewer Name *Email ID *Paper ID *Paper Title *Manuscript StructureTitle clearly reflects manuscript content *YesNoAbstract clearly states problem, method, and outcome *YesNoManuscript follows standard research structure *YesNoResearch contribution clearly stated *YesNoFigures & Tables IntegrityAll figures cited in manuscript text *YesNoNot ApplicableAll tables cited in manuscript text *YesNoNot ApplicableEquations numbered and referenced *YesNoNot ApplicableReferences QualityReferences complete and traceable *YesNoAll references cited in text appear in reference list *YesNoCitation style consistent throughout manuscript *YesNoEthical ScreeningUncited borrowed figures/tables detected *YesNoCopyrighted material copied without attribution *YesNoVisible plagiarism indicators detected *YesNoResearch CompletenessResearch problem clearly described *YesNoMethodology present *YesNoResults section clearly presented *YesNoConclusions supported by results *YesNoExperimental TransparencyExperimental setup or dataset described *YesNoComparison with existing methods included *YesNoAblation study included *YesNoNot ApplicableEditorial Review DecisionFinal Editorial Recommendation *Suitable for Peer ReviewReject at Editorial LevelJustification Statements *Conflict of InterestI confirm that I have no conflict of interest with this manuscriptSubmit
